Written by Terry Smith

Our site is reader supported so when you click a link to Amazon we may earn an affiliate commission.

UK’s best lawn rollers that are heavy duty 👷‍♂️ *actually tested to level a lawn from scratch*

This article was last updated on April 23rd, 2022 at 6:14 am

There is some conflicting information concerning using a lawn roller out there on the internet, so who do you trust? Anonymous reviews, or me, an ordinary bloke that shows you how to level a lawn step by step (in fact I literally show you how to restart a lawn 🙂 ) and includes the best heavy duty lawn roller, and that so happens to be one of the cheapest options as well! Sadly mines out of stock – you bought it right out following my recommendations last year 🙂 but I learn’t a thing or two on some other rollers whilst landscaping and there’s a couple even better than mine that I used – one being the AL-KO Hobby GW50 50cm Lawn Roller though too pricey for single use (don’t worry I have some bargains in here)! I’m tired of the hard sell rubbish, I only do facts. Let’s face it, we are all bored of a list of products with no proof of doing or using. I’d hazard a guess knowing the few genuine garden reviewers like me, only a handful have actually picked up a lawn roller (or tried to move a 72 Litre monster). Yeah, worrying! Describing them as heavy, durable, flattens lawns easily. With 0 experience 😀 and no idea of how much work it takes to push one. Oh well, no worries of that in my review. Here’s me with the old beastie that I’ve tested and given a real working over:

Me with my personal lawn roller

Not only the buying do I have in mind, I’m going to show you how to use a lawn roller as well if you’re interested or new to the game 🙂 And show you the differences between a heavy duty lawn roller and one more suitable for occasional home use.

Best lawn roller for home and occasional use: Einhell GC-GR 57 Garden Roller
Best lawn roller that’s towable and commercial quality: Brinly PRC-24BH 270-Pound Combination Push/Tow Poly Lawn Roller – currently out of stock but if you want the best of the best this is definitely it.
Sensible alternative to the Einhell: Coopers of Stortford Lawn Roller
Budget pick: Lawn Roller By Garden Gear
Heavy duty pick: AL-KO Hobby GW50 50cm Lawn Roller – or the larger Brinly used daily in commercial setups to great effect!
If the AL-KO IS unavailable: The Handy THGR Push or Pull Behind Steel Lawn Roller
Decent mid range pick: Greenkey Lawn Roller currently out of stock but very similar to the Coopers for much less money so we will give this a chance to come back

Get the most out of the best lawn roller

There are still many of us experienced gardeners who see the benefits of using such a tool. Using one of the best lawn rollers, one that isn’t too heavy or light, and using it at the right time and for the right purposes (especially when levelling the final stages with a bit of sand), is the key and will lead to your lawn looking absolutely fantastic. Trust me, I have documented why rolling the seed into your ground is so important and wouldn’t have produced the same results without one. It’s the best way to compact soil in my mind.

How to use a lawn roller

Let me first say that you don’t want to be going out there and rolling over your lawn every day for long periods of time as it can cause the soil to become too compact and this leads to a lack of aeration. You should also avoid using a lawn roller on very wet soil for the same reason. Slightly damp or moist soil is perfect, but not overly so.

One of the best times to use a lawn roller is when you are establishing a new lawn, or laying down some new seed/overseeding. I recently did this very thing, so I thought I’d spend a minute or two telling you how I did it here, and even shared a couple of photos with you. Before I even showed any seed, I used my trusty Garden Gear Heavy Duty galvanised steel roller to go over the area to get rid of troughs and ensure it was as level as possible. I’ve had this roller for a few years as you can tell by the wear and tear, scratches and such, but this is only superficial and that tool still does an amazing job. Being big, strong, and green, I’ve nicknamed it ‘the hulk’ (Unfortunately, due to covid-19, this product is unavailable on amazon at the moment, but there are some pretty good alternatives in our reviews section of this page which I’ve tested).

My trusty Garden Gear lawn roller, AKA ‘the Hulk’ still has plenty of life in her.

Once I was happy with the lay of the land, so to speak, I sowed my grass seed using a seed spreader to get an accurate 250g per square metre, raked the soil over, and then used my lawn roller again to go over the whole area. Doing this will encourage improved germination of the seeds by giving them all better contact with the soil.

You can see what the lawn looked like after this in this picture: –

Lawn well on its way – garden sprinkler helping considerably.

Now, you won’t really be able to tell from the photo, but despite my best efforts to level the garden beforehand, I still noticed some high spots afterwards when some of the grass had started to grow.

To rectify this, I simply laid down some lawn sand in those areas that needed bringing level, and grabbed ‘the Hulk’ once more to roll over everything until I was happy with the results. Here you can see what I’m talking about:

Using sand and a garden roller is a great way to level out your new lawn.

 

I’m lucky enough not to really suffer from pests such as moles digging up my lawn, but if you do have a problem with this(here’s the best mole traps), a good lawn roller can help you repair the damage caused and have your garden looking nice again in no time. Even if you don’t have pests, the winter frost can cause your previously perfect lawn to accumulate a few bumps and lumps, so It’s a good idea to have a lawn roller hanging around in the shed. I often use HSS for all sorts – diggers, ladders, you name it so I thought I’d give them a mention – not the best video but the content is bang on and re-iterates much of what I’ve explained you here:

The best lawn rollers are excellent for getting the ground flat and uniform before laying down seed, and also afterwards to get rid of any air that may be trapped. Just like with grass seed, rolling over the soil will help it to establish itself properly by giving it a better connection to the soil.

What you should know about a lawn roller

There’s some seriously important things to consider when buying a lawn roller. Firstly did you know the smallest and largest are so far apart that the larger is three times the size? And did you know said monster roller takes a big strong person to use? Did you know some are metal drums but others plastic? But, but, lets say you knew that, did you know a 72 litre roller may not be as effective as a 50 litre version due to the width and therefore weight ratios and force applied to the ground? 🙂 I can go on all day. I know it’s pretty sad but humour me 😀 Not all lawn rollers will work for everyone and so it’s important to understand the differences and what makes a quality lawn roller vs a cheap nasty one that won’t last five minutes. It’s all in the detail so let’s take a look:

What is a scraper bar and do I need one?

A scraper bar is designed primarily to stop dirt and soil that sticks to the roller coming back onto your lawn. You definitely want one as I know from when I started my lawn from scratch. The dirt will annoy you as it sticks. If on the other hand you’re rolling something like sand that isn’t going to grab the roller you might not want one. Personally, I wouldn’t use a roller without and I don’t want you to either so all the rollers in my review will have one 🙂

Lawn roller with scraper bar

However some work better than others like the Brinly and another quality option with regards to this is the AL-KO. Some are fitted closer and therefore remove more material. The Coopers being an example of this but being as close as it is, sometimes it’ll snag – there are certainly drawbacks – the better the clean, the more likely a problem! Some scrapers are adjustable too, like the AL-KO and the Handy

Plastic or metal drum

Interestingly metal isn’t necessarily a sign of quality. Te best roller on this entire review for quality, size, and built well enough to be towed is the Brinly. The heavy duty thick plastic won’t be punctured by sharp stones, despite the huge weight involved. The even more interesting thing is the metal drums are more likely to leak. Now there’s an easy solution to that – use sand. I have some issues with that though – first is sand is heavier density, so it means that, great you’ll have a heavier roller, but you won’t be able to empty it meaning manoeuvrability when not in use is out the window, and sand also costs money! Water is nearly free!

Size and weight ratio

Following on from the sand debate. It should be known that sand is about 1.5 times more dense when measured by volume. So let’s assume you make the budget pick Lawn Roller By Garden Gear. This will take 30 litres of water. Actually you can really ramp up performance filling this with sand and this will give about 45kg of weight. I know, we always think water is heavy 🙂 and it is, but sand is far heavier still including gaps.

If you’re trying to level ground and it really needs compacting I would take advantage of a unit (aside from the massive Brinly) that has a wide diameter like the AL-KO Hobby GW50 50cm Lawn Roller or CoopersThe reason being is quite straight forward – more pressure per square inch down means more compacting – it’s really that simple.

The Best Lawn Rollers Reviewed UK

So, now you know what the best lawn rollers are used for, and how to use them correctly, I think it’s about time that we had a closer look at the best lawn rollers available to us gardeners in the UK at the moment. Covid-19 has seriously limited our choices, but there are still a couple of gems you can get your hands on. We will, of course, update this page with other products once they become available again.

For those of you on a tighter budget, there are still a few good options available to you, and one of them is this lawn roller from Einhell. The main roller is made from coated metal, 1.5mm thick, so it certainly isn’t what you’d call flimsy. It is also a decent size, measuring 32cm in diameter and being 57cm wide, allowing you to cover a medium sized lawn in a short time. I was actually surprised at how light this lawn roller felt when it arrived when compared to some of the others that I’ve used before, and after checking it on the scales I realised I’d guessed right as it only weighed around 10 kilograms when empty.

With a maximum capacity of 46 litres, you can soon add the weight you require through adding sand or water, and the closable opening located on the side of the roller does make it easy, especially if you use a hose like I did. This opening also has the added benefit of making emptying the tool out afterwards for an easier walk back to the garage.

In the product description, it says that there is a dirt wiper than can be adjusted on either or both sides, and while there certainly is a dirt wiper, and it works well for the most part, I could not for the life of me work out how to adjust it, and the instructions that came with the product were far from helpful in this regard.

Another minor gripe that I have is that the handle was a little too short for me and I felt like I had to lean over while pushing the tool. I’m around average height at 5ft 10” so the taller of you might want to consider looking somewhere else – there’s a comfortable angle and I couldn’t find it.

Apart from these little complaints, I have to say that this is a decent lawn roller for the price and it will suit people with small to medium sized gardens, but don’t expect it to flatten out very large lumps or tackle big jobs. For most ordinary folks though, it’ll do just fine once it’s filled with water.

If you have the money to spare, you can’t really go wrong with our number one pick for best lawn roller: the Brinly PRC-24BH push/tow poly roller. Unlike most lawn rollers that are made of metal, Briny’s exceptional product is constructed of the highest quality polyethylene; a very robust type of plastic. What this means for you, is that your lawn roller won’t be getting dented from impacts, and will never rust. In short, this is a very durable tool, and sure to have a long working life.

This lawn roller, like most of these products, can be filled with either water or sand to give it the weight you require, and this particular model can be filled with up to 28 gallons (that’s about 103 litres in UK money), which equates to about 120kg, and that’s a lot of weight.

Of course, you won’t need to fill it to the limit for most home gardening tasks, and it is actually very easy to push around thanks to a robust set of handlebars and a smooth rolling action. If you have a large garden, you can attach the Brinley lawn roller to a small tractor or ATV tow bar, fill her to the maximum weight and go for it. The solid steel frame will keep the roller stable, and the extra weight will make sure those lumps and bumps get eradicated.

I have to say, I was impressed with the short time I had hands on with this lawn roller. It just feels like a quality product, and I think it is worth paying the extra for if you can. It really is easy to assemble, is top notch when it comes to build quality, and really does what it’s supposed to. Heres a super easy to follow demo of complete assembly and it has a few golden nuggets in there, especially about tightening the drum cap:

We used it to great effect when compacting sand and finding an uneven level on some artificial grass we laid – we couldn’t use a wacker plate because it pushed the levels about too much and trying to keep that gradient wasn’t working. I will say though it wasn’t quite perfect – if you look at the picture you can see the odd wobble. I wouldn’t blame the roller though 😀

Used the lawn roller to great effect when compacting sand base for artificial grass that we laid

Even the scraper bar seemed to work better than most products I’ve used or tested, and really did clear debris the way the maker intended. It’s little details like this why I give top marks from me for this combination push/tow lawn roller.

A little bit further up on the price scale than both the Einhell and the Coopers is the AL-KO hobby lawn roller is available for around 115 pounds at the time if writing, but is it worth shelling out the extra over the aforementioned competitors? Well, in a nutshell, I’d have to say yes (but only for frequent use). Does it have parts or features that the others don’t? I’d have to say no. Is it particularly larger? Again, I’d have to answer in the negative.

The reason I would spend the extra pennies for this one over the other two, is simply down to build quality. It just looks, and feels, better made. Everything from the solidity of the handles and frame, down to the cap on the drainage hole, has a more robust feel and gives you more confidence in the product and its expected longevity. I really felt this was better than my old Hulk when I tested it and obviously commercially we give them a good battering. If you’re only planning a lawn of your own then probably better to stick with a cheaper option:

AL-KO Hobby GW50 50cm Lawn Roller – heavy duty build quality

The 44cm diameter and 50cm long drum is big enough to handle usage in most average sized gardens in the UK, and once filled with sand it has more than enough weight behind it to flatten out common lumps and bumps. Empty, this lawn roller was so light that I was worried it wouldn’t be up to the task even when filled, but I am happy to say that this wasn’t the case and the tool performs its intended tasks well. Filling it with sand is no joke – this thing takes over 80kg so order four 25k bags of dry sand if you want to make the most of this tool.

I do have to say that although this arrived in very good condition for Sean (my landscape buddy) and had no issues, there have been one or two complaints from other customers, so it might be a quality control issue or maybe just depends on the supplier – stick with the manufacturer and you can’t go too far wrong. Overall though, most feedback has been positive, and like I said, the model I tested had no issues whatsoever and felt very strong in the hand.

Pros:

  • Most heavy duty well built of all the models I tested
  • Ideal for commercial use

Cons:

  • Can you justify the outlay for singular use?

I couldn’t leave out the The Handy THGR Push or Pull Behind Steel Lawn Roller this time around, it’s a direct competitor to the AL-KO and even starts matching up stats to the BrinlyNot surprising that it’s fast becoming a best seller and twenty quid cheaper than the AL-KO too – food for thought when considering everything I’ve said positively about both those two models!

At 48cm the barrel is almost identical to the AL-KO – it has a decent shaft that doesn’t look or feel flimsy and the roller itself is smooth without much concern of the scraper catching – the reason I say that is you pick the depth – a very nice touch on this unit:

The Handy THGR Lawn Roller – pick your own scraper height that suits you

The scraper adjustment is actually larger than the AL-KO and probably the most adjustment of all rollers in the UK. So if you need more flexibility then this may well be the pick for you. Let’s look at the specs:

It holds 120kg – so inline with the Brinly and more than the AL-KO – you’re starting to get the feeling this is the diamond in the rough and I don’t blame you 🙂

Well there are a couple of issues, over the many sold some complain of water leaking – I have to say, it’s not many but does happen and being strips of metal the odd one bends which again isn’t surprising with the weight involved.

My personal opinion is this is a quality unit – I prefer the AL-KO for now mainly because I’ve tested it – but I’ll give this a go between now and the next update and report back. I certainly wouldn’t rule this lawn roller out!

5. Coopers of Stortford Lawn Roller Heavy Duty Steel Cylinder - The Richmond

Available for the same sort of price tag as the Einhell, is the Coopers of Stortford Lawn Roller. Also, like the Einhell, it has one or two minor flaws, yet overall is still a pretty good budget choice. But first, the positives. Out of the box, it is pretty easy to assemble, and weighs around 13kg empty, so you’re not breaking your back moving it around. If filled to the max with water, you can expect it to weigh around 72kg, and that increases to 102kg when maxed out with sand.

The drum has a diameter of 42cm, which is larger than that of the Einhell lawn roller, however, it is 7cm shorter in length at 50cm. I have to say I liked the feel of the handles on this product. The soft rubber grip feels nice in the hands, certainly more so than cold steel in the winter, and I also like the fact that the handles are foldable for storage purposes. I still felt a little stooped over when using this lawn roller, but not as much as when using the Einhell.

On the side of the main drum is where you find the hole for filling and draining the roller, and it comes with a drain plug that doesn’t require any tools to remove or seal. Now, this has its pros and cons. On one hand it makes things easier when you’re filling or emptying, but I found that it didn’t seal 100% and allowed water to leak out. It wasn’t a lot, at least not on the item I tried out, but it was something I noticed. I didn’t see anything when it was filled with sand though.

The full-length scraper was probably the hardest part of the assembly process, but I got it on in the end, and it does work as intended, so I can’t complain there. Performance-wise, it is about what you would expect for the price – the scraper will snag on the drum if not aligned – it’s fitted tight. It will take care of all general gardening duties as intended, and even a few bigger high spots as long as you go over that area a few times in quick succession.

To sum it up, the Coopers lawn roller is about what I would expect for the price. Sure, it isn’t perfect but will keep most people happy for general use.

At just over 50 pounds, the Greenkey lawn roller is the cheapest of our featured products, but I’d say it holds its own against most of its competitors. There are a few places that you can see where the costs have been cut, for example the drum diameter is the smallest amongst this group of lawn rollers at only 30cm. It is also the smallest in width, measuring 42cm. I did find the handles a little short too, just like the Einhell, but I was grateful for the rubber grips, and the fact they can be folded over when storing the tool away.

The filling hole is only around an inch or so in diameter, so you’ll need to use a funnel to fill it with sand, but this is quite common for lawn rollers in this price range. There is a rubber stopper to prevent the water or sand leaking out, and I had no issues with it the entire time I was testing the product.

I filled the Greenkey lawn roller with a couple of bags of dry kiln to speed up the process, and once filled I found that it had enough weight to handle the job at hand. I had to roll over the same spot from different angles a few times to get any high spots out that were anything but small, but for the price that was to be expected, I suppose.

The metal material used for the drum did seem a little on the thin side to me, and I wouldn’t be surprised if dents would start to appear after a bit more use, but again, you get what you pay for.

The Greenkey lawn roller would suit someone with a small garden, who will not be using the tool that often, maybe just after the winter to get rid of a few bumps, to seed a new lawn, or to lay down some sod. It’s not a bad product at all, but it isn’t the best out there.

What can I say, I’ve left the best till last in my mind. Price point it wins hands down. I personally fill mine with sand. Nice dry sand that’ll make the process a breeze. Be sure to top it right up. You don’t want it slapping about in your hand.

The simple truth of this product is that it’s under priced. With 42cm width, galvanised steel, and a 12 month guarantee, it’s not hard to see why this sells very well indeed. It did the job nicely for me and on top of that when I was using it I found the grip to be pretty good too.

If you want me to be picky for a bit of balance, I would probably tell you the assembly was a little longer than I’d like but well within the range of normal for assembling a lawn roller. Buy with confidence.

Garden Gear Heavy Duty Galvanised Steel Lawn Roller

As you can see, even with covid-19 limiting our options, there are still some products out there for you, no matter what your budget allows for. To be honest, any of the cheaper products here would be just fine for smaller gardens, and the more expensive Brinley model is an excellent choice for larger properties or people who will get more regular use out of their lawn roller.


About Terry Smith

I’m Terry Smith from gardentoolbox.co.uk, a professional landscape designer, hobbyist gardener, and barbecue fanatic with 20 years experience building and restoring. So as you go through my site you'll watch me document some of the professional garden installs I make as well as the major projects I take on at home. While sharing those experiences and guiding you, I'll be recommending some great tools I use to enable this along the way so you can really buy in confidence. Always feel free to pop me a message: info@gardentoolbox.co.uk

View all posts by Terry Smith

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.